This product presents information about the conceptual model of causal pathways for the Maranoa-Balonne-Condamine subregion, which was developed using methods outlined in the companion submethodology M05 (as listed in Table 1) for developing a conceptual model of causal pathways . The application to the Maranoa-Balonne-Condamine subregion is described in Section 22.214.171.124, with more specific details in the individual sections that follow.
Conceptual models are abstractions or simplifications of reality. A number of conceptual models are developed for a BA, including conceptual models for geology, groundwater and surface water, which underpin the numerical modelling.
Another type of conceptual model is a conceptual model of causal pathways, which characterises the causal pathway, the logical chain of events ‒ either planned or unplanned ‒ that link coal resource development and potential impacts on water resources and water-dependent assets. The conceptual model of causal pathways brings together a number of conceptual models developed in a BA, and might be expressed in a variety of ways, with narrative, pictorial graphics, and influence diagrams all important.
The causal pathways play a critical role in focusing the BA on the most plausible and important hazards, defined as events, or chains of events, that might result in an effect (change in the quality or quantity of surface water or groundwater). The causal pathways associated with these hazards underpin the construction of groundwater and surface water models, and frame the assessment of the severity and likelihood of impacts to water-dependent assets. A water-dependent asset is an asset potentially impacted, either positively or negatively, by changes in the groundwater and/or surface water regime due to coal resource development. Some assets are solely dependent on incident rainfall and will not be considered as water dependent if evidence does not support a linkage to groundwater or surface water that will be impacted by coal resource development.
The construction of causal pathways requires the Assessment team to first synthesise and summarise the key system components, processes and interactions for the geology, hydrogeology and surface water of the subregion (as presented in Section 2.3.2). Emphasising gaps and uncertainties is as important as summarising what is known about how various systems work.
Section 2.3.3 presents the development of a landscape classification, which aims to systematically simplify a complex system that contains a large number of assets identified by the community. The landscape classification describes the main biophysical and human ecosystems, and provides a high-level conceptualisation of the subregion at the surface. Most assets are related to one or more landscape classes, which are defined for BA purposes as ecosystems with characteristics that are expected to respond similarly to changes in groundwater and/or surface water due to coal resource development. Landscape classes are present on the landscape across the entire subregion and their spatial coverage is exhaustive and non-overlapping. Conceptually, landscape classes can be considered as types of ecosystem assets, which are ecosystems that may provide benefits to humanity .
- baseline coal resource development (baseline), a future that includes all coal mines and CSG fields that are commercially producing as of December 2012
- coal resource development pathway (CRDP), a future that includes all coal mines and CSG fields that are in the baseline as well as those that are expected to begin commercial production after December 2012.
The difference in results between CRDP and baseline is the change that is primarily reported in a BA. This change is due to the additional coal resource development (ACRD) – all coal mines and CSG fields, including expansions of baseline operations, that are expected to begin commercial production after December 2012. To ensure consistency with Office of Groundwater Impact Assessment (OGIA) reporting, the baseline in the Maranoa-Balonne-Condamine subregion includes all CSG projects that are reported in the 2014 annual report for the Surat cumulative management area.
Figure 4 illustrates this fundamental comparison of these futures, with the baseline in the top half of the figure and the CRDP in the bottom half of the figure. It emphasises that in order to assess potential impact on assets, it is important to compare the changes of two types of variables at specific points in space and time:
- hydrological response variables, the hydrological characteristics of the system that potentially change due to coal resource development (for example, drawdown (Figure 3) or the annual streamflow volume)
- receptor impact variables, the characteristics of the system that, according to the conceptual modelling, potentially change due to changes in hydrological response variables (for example, condition of the breeding habitat for a given species, or biomass of river red gums).
Figure 3 Generic example of drawdown at a specific location over time for the baseline coal resource development (baseline) and coal resource development pathway (CRDP). The difference in drawdown between CRDP and baseline is due to the additional coal resource development (ACRD)
The lighter shades indicate the uncertainty in results. Model spin-up period is a warm-up period for the models.
Figure 4 The difference in results between the coal resource development pathway (CRDP) and the baseline coal resource development (baseline) provides the potential impacts due to the additional coal resource development (ACRD)
Section 2.3.5 details the hazard analysis, using the Impact Modes and Effects Analysis (IMEA) method, as described in companion submethodology M11 (as listed in Table 1) for hazard analysis , and illustrated in Figure 5. Potential causal pathways for both baseline and CRDP are identified by considering:
- activities – planned events associated with a CSG operation or coal mine. For example, activities during the exploration and appraisal life-cycle stage in a CSG operation include drilling and coring, ground-based geophysics and surface core testing. Activities are grouped into components, which are grouped into life-cycle stages
- impact causes – activities (or aspects of an activity) that initiate a hazardous chain of events
- impact modes – the manner in which a hazardous chain of events (initiated by an impact cause) could result in an effect (change in the quality or quantity of surface water or groundwater). There might be multiple impact modes for each activity or chain of events
- effects – changes in the quantity or quality of surface water or groundwater. An effect is a specific type of an impact (any change resulting from prior events).
The italicised text is an example of a specified element in the Impact Modes and Effects Analysis. (a) In the simple case, an activity related to coal resource development directly causes a hydrological change which in turn causes an ecological change. The hazard is just the initial activity that directly leads to the effect (change in the quality or quantity of surface water or groundwater). (b) In the more complex case, an activity related to coal resource development initiates a chain of events. This chain of events, along with the stressor(s) (for example, surface water (SW) flow and total suspended solids (TSS)), cause a hydrological change which in turn causes an ecological change. The hazard is the initial activity plus the subsequent chain of events that lead to the effect.
This product only specifies the causal pathways from coal resource development to hydrological response variables (see Figure 4). For BAs undertaking receptor impact modelling, the subsequent causal pathways (from hydrological response variables to impacts on landscape classes and water-dependent assets) are reported in the companion product 2.7 (receptor impact modelling). These causal pathways are reported for only those landscape classes with potential hydrological changes, as reported in product 2.6.1 (surface water numerical modelling) and product 2.6.2 (groundwater numerical modelling). Note, however, that companion product 2.6.1 (surface water numerical modelling) and product 2.7 (receptor impact modelling) are not produced for the Maranoa-Balonne-Condamine subregion, as explained in Section 126.96.36.199.
Product Finalisation date
- 2.3.1 Methods
- 2.3.2 Summary of key system components, processes and interactions
- 2.3.3 Ecosystems
- 2.3.4 Baseline and coal resource development pathway
- 188.8.131.52 Developing the coal resource development pathway
- 184.108.40.206 Water management for the coal resource developments
- 220.127.116.11 Gaps
- 2.3.5 Conceptual model of causal pathways
- 18.104.22.168 Methodology
- 22.214.171.124 Hazard analysis
- 126.96.36.199 Causal pathways
- 188.8.131.52 Gaps
- Contributors to the Technical Programme
- About this technical product