Appendix A Effects, stressors and impact causes for the Gloucester subregion

A.1 Coal seam gas operations

Table 12 Unique effects (for coal seam gas operations) identified during the Impact Modes and Effects Analysis for the Gloucester subregion

Effect

Frequency

SW quality

117

GW quality

50

SW volume

25

GW quantity

14

Change in GW pressure

10

SW directional characteristics

10

GW composition

7

SW flow

6

Aquifer properties

2

GW flow (reduction)

1

Soil quality

1

SW = surface water; GW = groundwater; SW flow = change in surface water flow volume; GW composition = mixing groundwaters of different composition (in terms of natural dissolved solids)

Table 13 Unique stressors (for coal seam gas operations) identified during the Impact Modes and Effects Analysis for the Gloucester subregion

Stressor

Frequency

TSS

68

Pollutants (e.g. metals, trace elements, sulfides or phosphorous)

39

TDS

34

Hydrocarbons

32

SW flow

30

Drilling mud products

13

GW flow

12

Change in GW pressure

11

GW composition

8

pH

6

Chemicals

4

Hydraulic fracturing chemicals

4

Organic pollutants

4

Aquifer properties

2

Change in GW pressure increase

1

Soil quality

1

Subsidence

1

SW composition

1

SW = surface water; GW = groundwater; TSS = total suspended solids; TDS = total dissolved solids, salts; SW or GW flow = change in surface water or groundwater flow volume; GW or SW composition = mixing waters of different composition (in terms of natural dissolved solids); Pollutants = anthropogenic contaminants

Table 14 Unique impact causes (for coal seam gas operations) identified during the Impact Modes and Effects Analysis for the Gloucester subregion

Impact cause

Frequency

Human error, accident (e.g. containment loss, digging, ignition, logging machine fault, formation variation)

33

Litter, spills

24

Containment failure/leaching/flooding (e.g. lining material failure, loss of holding capacity, pipe failure, dam failure)

21

Corridor/site vegetation removal

19

Diverting site/corridor drain line

17

Inevitable, Deliberate

13

Natural disaster (e.g. bushfire, flooding, earthquake)

8

Poor design, construction, implementation, management (e.g. abandonment practice, bore location, lack of knowledge, historical data records, sealing practices, geological characterisation)

8

Number of drilling control issues

5

Inappropriate disposal

4

Ignition following pipe failure

3

Incomplete grouting

3

Incidental to vegetation removal and compaction in pipeline corridor

2

Aquifer connected to coal seam

1

Aquitard leaks

1

Chemical interactions in soil

1

Depressurisation

1

Evaporation concentrates salt on surface

1

Fault closing

1

Fault open or opening

1

Incomplete reservoir knowledge, too much pressure

1

Increase baseflow

1

Interrupting ephemeral watercourses

1

Production of water

1

Salt mobilisation due to irrigation

1

A.2 Open-cut coal mines

Table 15 Unique effects (for open-cut coal mines) identified during the Impact Modes and Effects Analysis for the Gloucester subregion

Effect

Frequency

SW quality

95

GW quality

43

SW directional characteristics

23

SW volume/quantity

18

GW quantity/volume

10

SW flow

9

GW composition

6

GW directional characteristics

4

Change in GW pressure

2

GW flow

2

GW recharge

1

SW = surface water; GW = groundwater; SW flow = change in surface water flow volume; GW composition = mixing groundwaters of different composition (in terms of natural dissolved solids)

Table 16 Unique stressors (for open-cut coal mines) identified during the Impact Modes and Effects Analysis for the Gloucester subregion

Stressor

Frequency

TSS

72

Pollutants (e.g. metals/trace elements/sulfides/phosphorous)

42

SW flow

28

TDS

20

Hydrocarbons

19

pH

14

GW flow

8

Drilling mud products

6

GW composition

6

change in GW pressure

2

GW quantity/volume

2

Subsidence

1

SW composition

1

SW volume/quantity

1

SW = surface water; GW = groundwater; TSS = total suspended solids; TDS = total dissolved solids, salts; SW or GW flow = change in surface water or groundwater flow volume; GW or SW composition = mixing waters of different composition (in terms of natural dissolved solids); Pollutants = anthropogenic contaminants

Table 17 Unique impact causes (for open-cut coal mines) identified during the Impact Modes and Effects Analysis for the Gloucester subregion

Impact causes

Frequency

Human error, accident

19

Diverting site drain line

17

Corridor, site vegetation removal (e.g. removing rocks and topsoil)

14

Litter, spills

14

Containment failure, leaching, flooding (e.g. lining material failure, plant failure, mechanical failure, pipe fatigue)

12

Inevitable, Deliberate (e.g. mining below watertable, in recharge areas, removal of rock

mass, more than one aquifer intersected by pit)

11

Coal characteristics, waste characteristics, spontaneous combustion, bushfire

8

Poor design, construction, implementation, management (e.g. Abandonment practice, bore location, lack of knowledge, historical data records, sealing practices, geological characterisation)

8

Incomplete grouting

4

Ineffective revegetation due to (e.g. disease, poor topsoil, fire, weather, weeds)

4

Natural disaster (e.g. earthquake)

3

New topography, combined with timing of new vegetation and rainfall

3

Number of drilling control issues

3

Consolidation of loose backfill

1

Interrupting ephemeral watercourses

1

Last updated:
18 October 2018